Price Action Lab Blog

Premium Market Analysis

Market Statistics

End To Short Volatility Trade?

Spectacular drawdown levels in some popular volatility ETNs vindicate analysts who warned about the perils of the short volatility trade.

Many have warned about the bubble in short volatility trade using fundamental and technical analysis arguments. I have also done this in the context of trying to point out flaws in backtest results that some quants were using in support of these strategies.

When a trade gets crowded it implodes no matter how good backtests look. This is what happened to the short volatility trade but this time is interesting because it marked termination of XIV ETN after its NAV fell by more than 80%. Below is a drawdown chart of XIV.

No, this is not an error, the drawdown is 95% !!!

The financial industry but also regulators must get their act together. In recent times instruments have been designed with the only purpose of transferring wealth from the public to their designers. These include these volatility ETNs and weird things like cryptocurrencies and ICOs. The instruments are based on the same principles of offering hopes and dreams of quick riches to the public.

Of course, when something is public and offers wild dreams of easy money it gets crowded fast and then implodes. Those who conceived the scheme usually get away with it but they leave pain and destruction behind them.

As I wrote in a tweet yesterday, playing with volatility is like playing with fire. Volatility is fat-tailed and anyone who uses a strategy to exploit may face ruin as times passes. A sensible volatility strategy in my opinion is taking advantage of spikes via the use of positive convexity. This can be a long volatility calls but time decay costs money. There is no free lunch. Anyone who thinks there is free lunch at some point in time faces reality.

Below I have allowed free access to two premium articles for our subscribers last year where I showed that a typical volatility strategy has 75% probability of ruin among other things.

The Perils Of Volatility Strategies [Premium Articles]

Short Volatility Strategy Tail Risk [Premium articles]

Below are links to two more articles I have written about the perils of volatility strategies:

Non-Tradable Illusions: The Volatility Example

VIX Can Stay Low For Longer Than Shorts Can Remain Solvent

If you found this article interesting, I invite you follow this blog via any of these methods: RSS or Email, or follow us on Twitter

If you have any questions or comments, happy to connect on Twitter: @mikeharrisNY

Charting and backtesting program: Amibroker


Quantitative analysis of Dow-30 stocks and 30 popular ETFs is included in our Weekly Premium Report. Market signals for longer-term traders are offered by our premium Market Signals service. Mean-reversion signals for short-term SPY traders are provided in our Mean Reversion report.

Copyright Notice


  1. Drew Wells

    I think it is important to distinguish dangerously aggressive ways to short vol from conservative ways to short vol. Long SPY is synthetically short vol; short SPX cash-secured puts is explicitly short vol but has half the beta of long the notional equivalent SPY. Each, sized appropriately, can reasonably be regarded as conservative; and the addition of a properly sized put selling strategy to a diversified portfolio can be regarded as even more conservative than excluding it due to the diversification benefits of accessing the volatility risk premium. Shorting the front end of the VIX futures curve after that strategy has become ridiculously popular was idiotic. Shorting the middle of the curve, as ZIV does, while still more aggressive than selling SPX puts, proved, as expected, to be less problematic. ZIV took a big hit, but survived, leaving it up 74% over the last three years compared to 40% for SPY. Too many express opinions on bonds without distinguishing between categories of bonds; and too many do the same with short vol strategies.

    • I agree, thanks for the comments. I was mostly referring to those aggressive strategies that use XIV and VXX. Strategies with positive convexity can be used to short volatility with no significant risk except time decay in some cases.

Leave a Reply

Theme by Anders Norén